Have you ever had any experience with something like that? Ive been wearing size 11E Bates Chukkas for years, but Im thinking about switching to a Thursday President, but Im a little worried that I wont like them as much. Do they good enough to be kind of rain boots? I am strongly considering these Thursday Captain boots, but have one main concern that I didnt see addressed. the two upper lace hooks really do a job when i lace them up. Hello , I just wanted to say I love my Thursday Tobacco Captains Boots. A bit odd to wear when theres no precipitation to trudge through. I really do believe these boots are the best combination of construction, value, and materials. In theory thats based on the weight of a square foto of that leather, but in reality the actual weight of leather varies greatly depending on the animal and the tanning process and the phases of the moon. Funnily enough that kind of broguing when it originally was designed was for hunting in the British countryside and it was an absolute sin to wear any boots with broguing anywhere except for the outdoors. A post shared by Stridewise (@stridewise), boots youd want for hiking or outdoor work, Thursday President Boot Review in Tobacco | Rugged and Resilient for $199, Are Reigning Champ Hoodies & Sweats Worth It? I read in one of the other comments that you also own a pair of Vanguards, how do those compare to the Captains? Here are the most frequently asked questions from guys looking to buy Thursdays Captain boot. Can you just take them to any cobbler? The leather is very consistent in appearance, but if you like boots because the way they develop character, be patient: After a couple of weeks of wear, my shoes did indeed develop character and light creases and began to look well loved, while certainly remaining handsome enough for more dressed up wear. The construction, durability, design, comfort, brand, and above all the price have completely seduced me. Were told that adulthood starts at 18 or 21, but the older we get the more we realize that isnt true. The Vanguard review makes a lot of comparisons to the Captain that I think could be helpful, the main thing is they dont have the EVA strip in the sole so its more of a traditional workboot feel. I love them both, and am slightly leaning towards the Thursday due the more fashionable, less clunky toe box. Im used to low/medium quality boots like Docs 1460s and Clarks desert boots so Im not going to judge them by Alden or Viberg standards. Hey Austin thanks for commenting man. After finding and watching your youtube vids, I now have a pair of Captains (received last night), surprisingly purchased via Amazon.au Im in Sydney and some Edwin Selvedge jeans! When they were students, founders Connor Wilson and Nolan Walsh encountered a problem many of you have probably experienced: good boots are really expensive. https://stridewise.com/alden-indy-403-boot-review/, https://thursdayboots.com/products/mens-horween-natural-captain, https://stridewise.com/thursday-vanguard-boot-review/, Thursday Captain Boot Review (2022) | Why Its the Best Boot On the Market. However, Thursdays Rugged and Resilient line of leathers are tougher and stiffer and will take a few wears to soften up. I doubt they could be making much profit on these boots with their current prices, but as a consumer, I cant say Im complaining much. Sensing a gap in the market, the two launched the direct to consumer Thursday Boot Company with the goal of delivering the perfect hybrid boot at a low mark-up. Ive been wearing CBDs for the last 4-5 years as an all-around work and play boot and looking to upgrade to something a little more durable yet still holding a bit of that hybrid feel between fashion and function. 
Is it possible to stretch that spot upwards? TY! From narrow to wide, boot widths go B, C, D (this is normal), E, EE, and EEE. (I think.) Doing additional research, Im finding some reviewers comment the Thursdays start to fall apart by year 3 and the insole makes it not worth resoling. This does not cost you any extra money whatsoever, it just means the origin of the sale is tracked back to Stridewise. And I already own a Cognac Suede Scout. If youve read a few of my reviews, you know that I never hesitate to criticize an aspect of a boot that needs criticizing and Id never recommend anything I didnt love. That simply means that if you click the link and make a purchase, I may receive a small commission for sending you there. ey Ian, glad you like the site! Hey really happy the site could be useful, and its so cool to have a guy from Madagascar on the site! Maybe you should have gone with the wide fit if youre EE. Thanks a ton David! Can You Use Coconut Oil As a Leather Conditioner? You mentioned something above regarding their high heel. I got the Brandy full grain. Hey Nick, thanks for the highly informative review: heres a fashion/wear question. I just want a boot I can dress up or down for travel so I can pack light. Loved your reviews on the Thursday Captain here and on YouTube. I think Thursdays are pretty durable but if youre willing to spend more money on casual boots, its true the Iron Rangers have thicker leather and are a bit more suited for super casual beaters. When I got my Captains, I scoured them with a fine toothed comb: no loose threads, no loose grain, no welting issues, not even any discoloration. While nothing is perfect, no other boot in the industry has impressed me the way the Captain has. Goodyear Welt Vs. Blake Stitch Vs. Cement. That the first item of clothing a date looks at is your shoes. How long does it take to break in Thursdays Captains? Thanks for the 1-year update, Nathan! Would love to hear your opinion. Now theyre considered dressy! Hows that Dura EVA treating you after a year? I just wrote a review of the vanguard! Who Shouldnt Buy the Thursday Captain Boot? I think most cobblers would have Dainite soles, which is what the HM has and is pretty much exactly what Thursday has, although they make their own sole its more or less meant to mimic Dainite. As such its a bit less versatile and dressy than the Captain, plus the Red Wing has thicker leather thats harder to break in. Both shoes are Goodyear welted so they can both be resoled by any cobbler. Also managed to snag some AE Daltons on clearance + 20% 4th of a July sale + an additional 20% after complaining about some QC issues. Do you have any brand recommendations, or am I being a wuss and push those trees in more. Hi Nick, Thanks for a thorough review. Hi Nick, Great review! Good to see an Aussie doing well in NYC. After the outsole theres a cork-bed midsole, an anti-fatigue steel shank for arch support, soft leather lining on the inside, and their secret sauce: the Dura EVA comfort strip. Often used in athletic shoes, the EVA comfort strip has been updated and upgraded many times throughout several iterations of their boots. I do wear a lot of black but like the mild contrast of the dark brown. Ill take a good look at the welt as well because sometimes its uneven or poorly attached, like with the Indy: https://stridewise.com/alden-indy-403-boot-review/. Thank you for your help! The Higgins Mill heel is lower, yes. My Brown boots are made with a custom-developed, full grain leather thats strikingly similar to Horweens Chromexcel, which Id call the most beloved American boot leather. Once youve worked the balm into all the creases, gently wipe the boot down until theres just a thin film of balm on the shoe. Just put my Captains back in the box for return, failed eyelet on the upper left side of the left boot, eyelet completely failed, fully separated, theyre on their way back to the company, sorely disappointed as this was valued recommendation from Paul Stuart in New York City. Thanks for the good info. It flattened out and the shank came up and now the arch support is even better to be honest Bill! I originally had my eyes set on a pair of AE Higgins Mills, but after going though a couple exchanges with loose grain and stitching issues, am thinking of giving up and going with Thursday. My colleague wears these every day and they look great. Hi Nick, I was wondering if you would be able to a comparison of the Thursday boot Captain vs the Iron Ranger from Redwing? However, I am having a slight issue where my big toe rubs against the top of the toe box due to the slim profile. Lefarc won a gold medal from Leather Working Group in 2009, was named one of the two best tanneries in the Americas by World Leather Magazine in 2013, and they process leather for a wide variety of American boot companies I actually visited them for a fun series of videos in 2021. Would you say that the Rugged and Resilient colors can still dress up to business casual? Sure, those studs might not be quite as classic as a smooth leather sole, but its grippier while remaining pretty low profile. Theyre available in two widths, and the approach here is a little unusual. Hey Matthew, thanks for commenting. But since the right foot is fine maybe you could get a cobbler to stretch it out? I wore these during several particularly grueling storms and didnt once find myself skittering into a gutter, as I have with other brands. 
Today they sell a wide variety of mens and womens boots, dress shoes, and accessories, almost all of which cost under two hundred dollars. The Captain boot stands out in the market for its unusual silhouette: slimmer than a chunky work boot, but less dainty than dress boots. Meanwhile, the company insists the Rugged and Resilient line needs no care at all. The Captain and practically all of their boots are $199 on both their official site and Amazon, a ridiculous steal for the quality and comfort. Thursday sells direct to consumer so its tough to try before you buy, but theyve got free shipping and returns anywhere in the U.S., so you shouldnt feel nervous about accidentally getting the wrong width or size. Maybe inspired by Viberg boots? Any comment on this? Haha I hope your boots are happy in the Philippines! (Thursday recommends. What do you think of the Vanguard model? Im sorry for the delay in responding, my blog hid your comment for some reason. Haha a lot of guys cuss me out for costing them money. Enjoy! If you need something to handle a jobsite and electrical hazards you should perhaps look elsewhere, but for daily wear its far more durable than a sneaker. Thanks Mark! Do they really stand up to the test? Hi again Nick. By day: Manhattan-based journalist with reporting experience on four continents, published in Vice, Men's Health, Popular Science, and a bunch of other places.By night: ravenous consumer of anything and everything related to high end men's boots.Stridewise is where I nurture a maniacal obsession with footwear and share my findings. Thursday Captain Boots are cap toe service boots, which means they're leather lace up boots with stitching across the toes and a fairly low profile they're not big and blocky like work boots, they're streamlined and suitable for casual and business casual wear. Sorry to hear it, Andrew! Whites 350 Cruiser Review | The Best Work-Casual Boot? Its a hybrid dress/work boot, I wouldnt call it a workboot workboot. My choices are Black Captains and Brown President. If you can do that, and you get the rubber sole, theyre pretty good boots. Im about to order my first pair and looking at reddit reviews, Im terrified I will not notice and just use a defective product. What is your impression of the Thursday Wingtip? I mention on the Whites review and a few others. Not sure about the durability or quality control of these Captains, could have been a bad day at the factory, but Im inclined to look elsewhere for boots. Unlike some bulkier boots, the outsole dont form an especially chunky shelf around the upper its neat, sleek, and contributes to their ability to be dressed up. I mostly look for loose threads and loose grain, is the short answer. Then dab some leather balm on the rag and work it into all their creases. But I also see some terrible reviews of them including chunks of the rubber sole chipping off, separation of the sole from the upper, and peeling of the insole liner. Then I watched your YouTube reviews of the Thursday President. The leather is approximately 1.8 millimeters thick, about 0.4mm thinner than youll find in more chunky workhorse-y boots like the Red Wing Iron Ranger but thicker than the 1.0 millimeter leather uppers you might find on a dress shoe. It looks a lot like the popular Dainite sole, seen on countless boots over $350, but Thursday makes their own rubber that works just as well. What Exactly Is a Last, and Why Is It So Important? Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. On first wear, my left foot settled perfectly, but my right is struggling it a bit(feels like the heel is being strangled.. how long do you think it would break in? I mentioned the nifty, studded rubber outsole and after a lot of wear I found it offered excellent traction, as expected. AE should be embarrassed they sent them out. What a treat, I really appreciate your comment and am glad Stridewise helped you find a boot you love. Allen Edmonds takes care of the entire resole process for you for 150 bucks. Get what you mean about the feeling of walking on sand but man are they comfortable. Have never been sure about whether or not theyd work for motorcycle riders when people ask me, glad to hear theyre working for you! missed editing my full name (auto fill). Their Goodyear welt construction and water resistant leather mean your socks will stay dry in a rainstorm, theyre just not ideal for standing in a lake fishing all day. However, the Bates are $185 a pair and they dont seem to last more than a year or two before the leather tears, usually on the outside of the vamp, about an inch forward from the edge of the upper. Its true that the Thursday boots have a pretty high heel though. I was well into my career as a journalist in New York City before I finally realized that grown men dont walk around town in sneakers and, when its a little rainy, rubber galoshes. Again, this is particular to the Brown leather; many of their leathers, like the Terracotta in the video above, are better suited for casual wear and dramatic patina. Just wanted to follow up and say I purchased Thursdays captain boot as a result of your reviews. For me I really value versatility and cost, and I think Thursday wins in that regard. As for comfort, the leather and sole broke in easily, but foam + cork combo did take a few wears to conform to my feet. I think theyre less versatile though. Id definitely say the President would last longer, though. I prefer brown as its more versatile. One hundred percent of their leather comes from Tier 1 United States cattle, and its processed at Lefarc tannery in the leather hub of Len, Mexico. In an industry of hundred-year-old brands, Thursday Boot Company is one of the newest and most talked about boot companies out there. I think going from CDBs to Thursdays is a really good move, Thursdays arent all that much more expensive (considering how expensive boot get) but the quality is a lot better and the sole is easily replaceable. Hopefully one day. 1.8mm is between 4 and 5 ounces. Im looking to have it fill the gap for dressier nights out with slacks, chinos or jeans. How the Heck Do I Take Care of Chromexcel Leather? However, I am worried about the longevity, and also being able to resole them. I think what youre looking for is the Natural color https://thursdayboots.com/products/mens-horween-natural-captain thats light but not as outdoorsy. I ordered two sizes and one of them were absolutely terrible. It depends on the leather; there are over a dozen different kinds to choose from. Thursday threw all that out the window, offering just two widths: Standard, for D or E widths, and Wide for EE or EEE widths. I got the terra cotta color thinking it was a bit warmer and more versatile turns out its lighter than I thought & Im thinking it might show scuffs easier than the brown. I know early models of the boot had some issues but my newer ones are holding up really well, I guess thats all I can say about it! Cheers. Yeah if you take them to a cobbler I dont doubt they can stretch that out for you. How do you think the Thursday President compares to Bates Chukkas? Yeah the versatility is a huge selling point. Terrific! Hopefully you get a good pair next. These ar ethe two Im kind of stuck between right now. Two years ago I ordered a pair of their most popular boots, the Captain boot, to find out. So my experience, limited as it is, was that I got better QC with the Thursdays. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); See which boots suit your preferences and style. The fact that you wear all of the boots prior to reviewing them in order to give an more accurate and honest take on each product is very much appreciated. The following two tabs change content below. It depends on what environments youre planning to wear the boots in I guess, but you also have to take into account the Thursday is over a hundred dollars cheaper. Ed this means the world to me, thanks so much for leaving a comment, and Im glad my words rung true for you! Ended up less than the Captains. I quite like the look + color combo of having both the Arizona Adobe and the Matte Black but want to make sure they would be appropriate with a dress shirt and khakis. They feel good after only a few days wear, and they look very cool. I cant say Ive tried those Chukkas Im afraid! Having a thicker heel means my foot is tilted down and that causes an ache in the top of my foot if I walk too much with that. Im 62 and dont need to add extra height. Congrats on the purchase. After a couple weeks Im extremely happy with my purchase. Thoughts? A distinguishing feature is the toecap, but these arent your dads work boots. But now, thanks to your comparison with Thursday Boot Companys Captains you may have saved me $200. I am NOT going to wear these on trails or working outdoors, its more biz casual or just casual. By the way, leather is usually measured in ounces. That process is called hot stuffing and while Horweens recipe is proprietary, Thursday clearly does something very similar with their Chrome. This leatherages just right: they got character, but not scars. Many customers who wear EE widths have had success ordering size larger to accommodate their feet for footwear in our Standard width. Theyre very water resistant, though not technically waterproof. 
The sole of my boots are different than you have pictured, not a complaint just an observation. My question is, which color is much more versatile in terms of dressing business casual look and would be able to look bad ass with leather jackets? Hi Nick. Theyre not shiny/chromey like Thursdays Brown, Black, and Natural, but I think so long as you pick a boot that doesnt have shiny nickel/silver looking eyelets, it can do fine with biz caszh. Are the heels of Thursdays boots the same as RW, Wolverines, etc? They look like theyd be good bets for super snowy winters, theyre not waterproof but the storm welt is kind of an extra water resistant Goodyear welt. At $200, the Captain is a great looking boot, but Id rather spend more for Iron Rangers or similar and get a boot that will last if Thursday are more of a short term investment. 
(But again, returns are free, so I wouldnt sweat it.). Hi Nick, I am just curious on what size boot I should go for exactly, the reason being I live down under and yes you guessed it I do wear RM Williams boots and my size is 8 1/2 H UK size which they deem is there wide widthyour help would be greatly appreciated as I am very keen on getting a pair of Thursday Captain boots in brown. Hey Jones, for business casual yes, I think they work. I dont know, its hard to make a decision between the two, it really depends on your needs. What an excellent pair of boots! got excited leaving a post. So what the heck is Thursday Chrome? Love your stuff. The Bates have a relatively thin sole, and I like that, though I usually like my Bates a bit better after the heels are worn down a bit. Handsome and understated were my first impression, but the best thing? This is the key to Thursdays famous comfort. Any thoughts on the best all-around color? The only one I can get in there is the cheap plastic, but have plenty of the cedar ones. Today its called a custom made Dura EVA comfort strip, which Thursday says has a bit more bounce than older models. Yeah that happens with most leather boots, Stephen! And work boots are too clunky for the office, and fashion boots can be too dainty and feminine.
- Best Face Moisturizer
- Coach Purple Purse Leather
- Townhomes For Rent Kettering, Ohio
- American Eagle Men's V-neck T-shirts
- Makeup Forever Aqua Xl Eye Pencil
- No Drill Curtain Rod Brackets Lowe's
- Angelcare Bath Support Age
Share